Paypal button acts differently between staging site and real site

I have a staging site (http://cccofwv.org/staging/5545/give/) and a real site (https://cccofwv.org/give/) with a PayPal Donate button. When I click on the staging site button, it takes me to the page in paypal that I want. When I click the button on the real site it does not do the same thing. How can I make the real site behave like the staging site?