Home Page Settings for Blog

I have a static page in which I would like my homepage to show 2 of the most recent posts. I would do this by categorizing them as "showonfrontpage". Settings in Customize - Homepage settings are Homepage Displays: Static, Homepage: About, and Posts: Big Fish Blog Settings in Theme Options: Homepage/frontpage Only posts that belong to the categories selected here will be displayed on the front page Select Categories - ShowOnFrontPage Checked to enable Latest Posts on Static Frontpage For some reason, my homepage is showing all of the blogs, the Page where all of the blogs should be (BIG FISH BLOG) is showing only 2, and they aren't even categorized as "ShowOnFrontPage" The website is https://coppersculpture.com. Thank you.