Featured Post Slider

I've been using the featured post slider on my website http://jeanieandluluskitchen.com since I started using Simple Catch over a year ago. I went to update the posts featured on it today and now it only shows the first post I designated. There is no sliding to the other two featured posts and no little tabs on the bottom to even indicate that the other two posts are there. I've saved them and triple checked that I did it like I've always done. I logged out and closed my browser, then logged back in with no change. Any help would be appreciated! Thanks!