Continue Reading not showing up.

I am in the process of building my site using Simple Catch and the Continue Reading tag is not showing up. I use the insert more tag available while writing a post and it shows up when I select another theme, yet in this Simple Catch there seems to be something in the way. The post in question is on my homepage titled "Test Post". The link to my homepage is here: http://www.thecollegecook.com I've gone through several pages of the forum looking for an answer but have come up short. Any suggestions?